Transpower Upper North Island Grid Upgrade Proposal - List of submissions

Appendix 3

Published: 1 March 2008

Appendix 3 lists the submissions lodged that used a common layout and near identical wording. The sample that precedes the list is shown for indicative purposes only. These submissions were sent via a common website which gave the user an ability to select or de-select sections of text and whether they wished to appear. Variations in length and layout were the result of varying user inputs, though the text selected was in essence common.

Type A Sample

-----Original Message-----
From: TPCallin [mailto:TPCallin@mfe.govt.nz]
Sent:
To: rice-resources-ltd@clear.net.nz
Subject: FW: Grid Upgrade Submissions

-------------------------------------------
From: anonymous@createhosting.net.nz[SMTP:ANONYMOUS@CREATEHOSTING.NET.NZ]
Sent:
To: boisub@notowers.co.nz
Subject: Grid Upgrade Submissions
Auto forwarded by a Rule

***********************************************************
Name:
Phone:
Email:
Yes:         I/we wish to be heard in support of my/our submission at the public hearing, and expect I will need between one and two hours to present my evidence. I would like the location of the portion of the hearing which will receive my evidence to be held in a local venue near to where I live.
Submitter:   type in your name (again)
A:           copy of this submission has been emailed to Transpower.
Scope:       This submission covers all notices of requirements and applications for resource consents relating Transpower’s applications that will be heard by this Board of Inquiry. The references are NORs 27619, L07089, DES0011/07, RMR200621, DN/0006/07, 240/021, RM070209, and resource consents 34102, 34370, 34372, 34373, 34711, 34712, 116902, 116903, 116904, 116905, and any other NORs or resource consent applications that may subsequently be filed or altered. We oppose all of these NORs and applications for resource consent.
Re:          This submission relates to the notices of requirement and/or applications for resource consent, lodged by Transpower New Zealand Ltd for the North Island Grid Upgrade Project, and identified above.
Remote Name:
Date:

Address:
Reasons:

I am completely opposed to Transpower’s intention to build this un-needed line, as the demand growth projections of the Electricity Commission (2007 SOO) do not justify its construction. The scale and capacity of this proposed 400kV capable line is completely out of alignment with the expected requirements for transmission capacity into Auckland to meet demand growth in the next 40 years. The potential new generation capacity likely to be constructed in the Auckland region in the next 40 years has been grossly underestimated in an attempt to justify this line as one of national significance and urgency.

Better equal benefit alternatives to this proposed line are available that have a much reduced environmental impact, such as more generation in the Auckland region, duplexing and reconductoring of the Whakamaru A, B and C lines, use of HVDC transmission technology which will be less obtrusive and easier to underground, more extensive use of undergrounding of HVAC lines, and consideration of new conventional small scale 220kV transmission lines.

I oppose this line being built on a 65 metre wide easement, when a 600 metre wide easement, free of houses and workplaces, should be required as a precautionary principle to reduce future health risks and environmental impacts.

I oppose large scale HVAC transmission lines being built on narrow 65 metre wide easements because of the EMF emissions and ionized particle emissions that will come from this line, which have been proven to cause numerous diseases, including childhood leukaemia.

I oppose these applications because Transpower has falsely (and perhaps criminally) tried to justify the need for this line being built by using out of date and inaccurately high demand growth forecasts (2005 SOO), have not included the cost of environmental impacts in their justifications, and are providing misleading and inaccurate costings of the real alternative options to this line that should be considered.

Therefore:

I seek the following decision from the Board of Inquiry. That the application for Notices of Requirement and Resource Consents should be turned down completely, and Transpower directed to investigate generation, conservation and transmission alternatives that will avoid this line being built under any circumstances.

I explicitly do not want the Board of Inquiry to approve the applications subject to conditions – I want the applications turned down in whole.

Type A Submitters
Ref #	Name & Initials	Appear Y/N	Appear NS
0443	Addy, Sarah	Yes	No
0170	Aitchison, Raewyn	Yes	No
0169	Aitchison, Raewyn	Yes	No
0168	Aitchison, Trevor	Yes	No
1083	Alexander, Alan J	Yes	No
0455	Alexander, Ian	Yes	No
0456	Alexander, Liam Thomas	Yes	No
0364	Allen, Diane Margaret	Yes	No
0278	Allen, Andrew Thomas	No	Yes
0279	Allen, Karen Marie	No	Yes
0365	Allen, Andrew Richard	Yes	No
0856	Allison, Grant F	Yes	No
0857	Allison, Robert	Yes	No
0858	Allison, Winifred M	Yes	No
0420	Anderson, John Haare	Yes	No
0092	Anderton, Amanda	Yes	No
0993	Ashley Rocks Farm Ltd	Yes	No
1086	Athy, gerard	Yes	No
0869	Avery, Brendon & Bjorny	No	Yes
0441	Baldwin, Christina Isabel	Yes	No
0551	Bardsley, Carron	Yes	No
0677	Bardsley, David	Yes	No
0529	Barrett-Hamilton, Kirsty	Yes	No
0534	Barrett-Hamilton, Megan	Yes	No
0533	Barrett-Hamilton, Sean	Yes	No
0532	Barrett-Hamilton, Serita	Yes	No
0671	Bartlett, Aaron & Kristy	Yes	No
0661	Basnet, Bidya	No	Yes
0662	Basnet, Chuda	No	Yes
0113	Baxendine, David Hugh	Yes	No
0468	Bayes, Charles Ian	Yes	No
0311	Bayes, Colin & Kaye	Yes	No
0467	Bayes, Erolyn Amy	Yes	No
0055	Bell, Christine	Yes	No
0472	Bell, Malcolm & Janice	Yes	No
0743	Bishop, Glenys SA	No	Yes
0705	Bishop, Helen	Yes	No
0707	Bishop-Sime, Alexander IB	No	Yes
0045	Blackler, Christine	Yes	No
0046	Blackler, Gary	Yes	No
1053	Bonnar, Earl M	No	Yes
0524	Bowden, Stephen	No	Yes
0809	Bowker, Graham & Jane	Yes	No
0691	Brayshaw, Graeme & Carolyn	No	Yes
0890	Britten, Gayle	No	Yes
0891	Britten, Ross	No	Yes
0444	Brookman, James	Yes	No
0679	Brown, Aaron W	Yes	No
0097	Brown, Colin M	Yes	No
0463	Brown, Jared Hoera	Yes	No
0096	Brown, Keryn D	Yes	No
0538	Brownlie, Winston & Raewyn	Yes	No
0526	Bruno, Geof	No	Yes
0020	Burton, Trish	Yes	No
1245	Burwell, Barry Francis	Yes	No
1020	Burwell, Jessica A	Yes	No
0850	Burwell, Julie M	Yes	No
0657	Campbell, Greg	No	Yes
0913	Cao, LianQing	Yes	No
0910	Cao, Linda	Yes	No
0688	Carson, Vance S	Yes	No
0206	Casey, Carolyn Grace	Yes	No
0400	Cassidy, Jennifer Marie	Yes	No
0295	Cattell, Bruce Francis	Yes	No
0390	Cattell, Graham Dorian	No	Yes
0274	Chamberlin, Andrew Philip	No	Yes
0651	Chambers, Paul J	Yes	No
0650	Chambers, Vanessa O	Yes	No
0294	Chieng, Christine	Yes	No
0293	Chieng, Walter	Yes	No
0023	Childerhouse, Charlotte	Yes	No
0024	Childerhouse, Kathryn	Yes	No
0711	Clark, David J	Yes	No
0287	Clark, Gavin	Yes	No
0284	Clark, Lindsay	Yes	No
0283	Clark, Margaret	Yes	No
0282	Clark, Michelle Brenda	Yes	No
0917	Clark, Nicola	Yes	No
0712	Clark, Pamela	Yes	No
0285	Clark, Rachael	Yes	No
0071	Clarke, Alison	Yes	No
0072	Clarke, Darren	Yes	No
0353	Clearwater, Russell D & Leanne R	Yes	No
0338	Collier, Janeen	Yes	No
0269	Colquhoun, Muriel Roslyn	No	Yes
1027	Connor, Jason	Yes	No
1026	Connor, Rob	Yes	No
0205	Cooper, Bradley Thomas	Yes	No
0266	Coralie, Doughty Trust	Yes	No
0268	Cosgrave, Alvin Shane	No	Yes
0267	Cosgrave, Lynda Michelle	No	Yes
0384	Couch, Judith	Yes	No
0175	Cowley, Gerald James	Yes	Yes
0122	Curry, Charlotte	Yes	No
0033	Curry, Harold Oliver	Yes	No
0123	Curry, Jane	Yes	No
0121	Curry, Marilyn	Yes	No
1043	Daley, Rebecca	No	Yes
0373	Dalun, Yang	Yes	No
0678	Darley, Nicky	Yes	No
0339	Dartnell, Joanne	Yes	No
0125	Davey, Dallis Agnes May	Yes	No
0300	Davey, Michael	No	Yes
0659	Davies, Mandy	No	Yes
0655	Davies, Mandy K	Yes	No
0049	Dawson, Mike & Kasey	Yes	No
0179	De'Arth, Gary Brett	Yes	No
0112	Dinger, Anton Edward	Yes	No
0025	Disney, Stephen	Yes	No
0918	Dix, Kyllie	Yes	No
0725	Dixon, Christopher J	Yes	No
0726	Dixon, Linda J	Yes	No
0727	Dixon, Sophie	Yes	No
0290	Dobbs, Chloe	Yes	No
0462	Downer, Aaron Paul	Yes	No
0459	Downer, Aaron Paul	No	Yes
0105	Dunn, Anne	Yes	No
0106	Dunn, Robert William	Yes	No
1064	Earl, Roger A	Yes	No
0437	Eastgate, Darryl R K	Yes	No
0442	Etheridge, John-Paul Augustus	Yes	No
0709	Evans, Greer	Yes	No
0064	Falconer, Brenda	Yes	No
0216	Findlay, Helen	Yes	No
0706	Fleming, Sheree	No	Yes
0034	French, Elizabeth Ann	Yes	No
0741	Garcia, Rafael S	Yes	No
0298	Gardner, Shelley	Yes	No
0243	Gare, Eva	No	Yes
0872	Gemmell, Amanda	Yes	No
0381	Gerrett, Trish	Yes	No
0155	Gibbons, Kristine May	Yes	No
0167	Gibbs, Shona	Yes	No
0173	Gilbert, Sandra Joy	Yes	No
0454	Gill, Erin	Yes	No
0457	Gill, Liam Thomas	Yes	No
0458	Gill, Sam Alexander	Yes	No
0264	Gilliver, Ian	No	Yes
1063	Given, Angela	Yes	No
1068	Gresham, Timothy P	No	Yes
1038	Gubb, Campbell B	Yes	No
1040	Gubb, David B	Yes	No
1036	Gubb, Murray B	Yes	No
1035	Gubb, Valerie J	Yes	No
0413	Habergham, Raewyn	Yes	No
1011	Hagan, Heather	Yes	No
1012	Hagan, Heather	Yes	No
1010	Hagan, Ken	Yes	No
0875	Harkan Ltd	Yes	No
0886	Harkan Ltd	Yes	No
0728	Hart, Margaret E	No	Yes
0729	Hart, Michael	No	Yes
0374	Harvison, Robert	Yes	No
0296	Hay, Michael James	Yes	No
0115	Hayes, Kathleen Mary	Yes	No
0118	Hayes, Marie Isabel	Yes	No
0114	Hayes, Peter Graham	Yes	No
0117	Hayes, Sarah Marie	Yes	No
0116	Hayes, Steven Peter	Yes	No
0156	Henderson, Margaret Anne	Yes	No
1249	Herbert, Sheryl	No	Yes
0889	Hicks, Adam	No	Yes
0888	Hicks, Nicole	No	Yes
0212	Hines, Rex Kelvin	Yes	No
0907	Hirokawa, Aya	Yes	No
0698	Hitchins, Mona B	No	Yes
0870	Hitchins, Walter H	Yes	No
0465	Hodgson, David	Yes	No
0464	Hodgson, Diane	Yes	No
1029	Hopping, Shirley & Denis	No	Yes
1007	Hughes, George P	Yes	No
1006	Hughes, Joanne R	Yes	No
0357	Huitema, Lizette	No	Yes
0292	Hunter, Miriam Ellen	Yes	No
0337	Hyland, Paul	Yes	No
0174	Jackson, Alison Jean	Yes	No
1052	Jakes, Natalie	Yes	No
0213	Jamieson, Kevin John	Yes	No
0403	Jenkins, Mark	Yes	No
0401	Jenkins, Melanie Jean	Yes	No
0176	Jones, Susan Bronwyn	Yes	No
0177	Jones, Vincent Paul	Yes	No
0877	Julian, Anne V	Yes	No
0878	Julian, Donald R	Yes	No
0446	Julian, Jacqueline Suzanne	Yes	No
0448	Julian, Liam Joseph	Yes	No
0447	Julian, Michael Donald	Yes	No
0449	Julian, Logan Michael	Yes	No
0354	Keene, Vicki Kay	Yes	No
0050	Kelly, Camille	Yes	No
0681	Kennedy, Eleena	Yes	No
0680	Kennedy, Eleena	Yes	No
0635	Kesby, Jacquiline	Yes	No
0634	Kesby, Stephen	Yes	No
0276	Kidd, Jayne Susan	No	Yes
0277	Kidd, Katherine	No	Yes
0275	Kidd, Michael Robert	No	Yes
0392	Kilfoyle, Barbara Louise	Yes	No
0391	Kilfoyle, Hugh Thomson	Yes	No
0026	Kravtsov, Pavel	Yes	No
0027	Kravtsova, Elena	Yes	No
0523	Lane, Geoffrey, Helen & Stewart	No	Yes
0171	Lepper, Stacey	Yes	No
0215	Letherman, Michael	Yes	No
0297	Li, Yujin	No	Yes
0756	Lichtwark, Colin J	Yes	No
0757	Lichtwark, Daniel C	Yes	No
0760	Lichtwark, Ida M	Yes	No
1242	Lichtwark, Irene Tatjana	Yes	No
0758	Lichtwark, Karoline M	Yes	No
0908	Lim, Mok-Hoon	Yes	No
0065	Lindsay, Leanne M	Yes	No
0060	Lloyd-Lewis, Gwyn	Yes	No
0924	Lochead, Tia	No	Yes
0204	Lorigan, Patricia Gaye	Yes	No
0864	Lusty, Andrew W	Yes	No
0541	Lyons, Roger Jack	No	Yes
0733	Macbeth, Brent J	Yes	No
0865	Mannell, Geoffrey T	No	No
0696	Mannell, Janette M	Yes	No
1028	Manual, Lesley	Yes	No
0372	Maojun, Zhou	Yes	No
0218	Mardell, Nina	Yes	No
1062	Markwell, Vanessa J	No	Yes
0048	Marquet, Vaughan Anthony	Yes	No
0867	Martin, Elizabeth	Yes	No
0866	Martin, Michael D	Yes	No
1034	Matthews, Henry R	Yes	No
1049	Matthews, Melody	Yes	No
0366	Maxwell, Mary Heather	Yes	No
0301	McColl, Peter James	Yes	No
0286	McCready, William Evans	Yes	No
0361	McCready Candace	Yes	No
0358	McCready Gillian	Yes	No
0360	McCready James	Yes	No
0359	McCready Stuart	Yes	No
0386	McCready, William Havelock	Yes	No
0236	McIlroy, Fiona Louise	No	Yes
0767	McIntyre, Tania L	Yes	No
0375	McKee, Brent	Yes	No
0376	McKee, Maree	Yes	No
0303	McKenzie, Greg & Sarah	Yes	No
0220	McKinnon, Carol Isabelle	No	Yes
0219	McKinnon, William Patrick	No	Yes
0387	McLaren, Anthony James	Yes	No
0388	McLaren, Lornelle Yvonne	Yes	No
0272	McLennan, Wayne	No	Yes
0308	McLeod, Quinn	Yes	No
0316	McNab, Alistair	Yes	No
0281	McPhee, Dean	No	Yes
0021	McQueen, Anita	Yes	No
0056	McQueen, Kristina	Yes	No
0320	Meale, Dean Russell	Yes	No
0321	Meale, Kay Marie	Yes	No
0059	Melis, Adriana AM	Yes	No
0382	Menzies, Jillian Mary	Yes	No
0438	Merts, Pieter F & Elisabeth M	Yes	No
0453	Millar, Craig Charles	Yes	No
0234	Millenium Investments (2002) Ltd	Yes	No
0409	Milne, Grant SE	Yes	No
0440	Morris, Karen Andrea	Yes	No
0738	Morrison, Maeve	No	Yes
0396	Mountford, Leonie	Yes	No
0393	Mulholland, Nigel Thomas	Yes	No
0312	Murdoch, Sally-Anne	Yes	No
1039	Murfitt, Michelle	Yes	No
0922	Nicholls, Vanessa R	Yes	No
0734	Nicoll, Natalya J	Yes	No
0066	Nienhuis, Eric JPM	Yes	No
0225	Noordzij, Pieter	Yes	No
0302	Norman, Vera Emma	Yes	No
0668	Ohug Power Equipment Ltd	Yes	No
0667	Ohug Power Equipment Ltd	Yes	No
0395	Oliver, Jessica	No	Yes
0439	O'Malley Brigit Clare	No	Yes
0894	Orange, Christina J	Yes	No
0527	Orange, Dr Kate	No	Yes
0239	Overington, Patricia	Yes	No
0099	Palmer, Samantha Beverley	Yes	No
0178	Parry, John	Yes	No
0880	Pascoe, Daniel W	Yes	No
0460	Pascoe, Gayle Patricia	Yes	No
0461	Pascoe, Ian Douglas	Yes	No
0879	Pascoe, Peter M	Yes	No
0637	Pearson, Linda Jayne	No	Yes
0841	Pellett, Selwyn	Yes	No
0067	Pencavel, Alan D	Yes	No
0022	Pencavel, Sheila	Yes	No
0735	Phillips, Peter J & Vicki R	Yes	No
0737	Polley, Helen P	No	Yes
0554	Poole, David Michael	No	Yes
0690	Read, Brent	No	Yes
0054	Ready, Daniel Mark	Yes	No
0656	Reese, Austin J	Yes	No
0658	Reese, Vanessa	Yes	No
0305	Reeve, Judith Maree	Yes	No
0304	Reeve, Stephen Maurice	Yes	No
0314	Reid-Hoff, Julie-Anne	Yes	No
0383	Riddell, Catherina N & Stuart J	Yes	No
0689	Rigby, Michelle	Yes	No
0664	Rigby, Steve	Yes	No
0755	Rihari, Moira	Yes	No
0868	Risi, Peter & Vickie	Yes	No
0920	Robertson, Jessica	Yes	No
0265	Rogers, Barry Woodward	No	Yes
1075	Rombouts, Cornelius & Johanna	Yes	No
0241	Rose, Angela	No	Yes
0530	Ross, Adam	Yes	No
0124	Ruegger, Markus Andreas	Yes	No
0172	Ruis, Elaine	Yes	No
0445	Russo, Rebecca	Yes	No
0470	Sargent Family Trust	Yes	No
1051	Sasanuma, Keiko	No	Yes
1002	Sattler, Warren L	No	Yes
0154	Saward, Karen	Yes	No
0630	Sceats, Janet	Yes	No
0921	Schenkel, Anne E	Yes	No
0531	Schoutens, John	Yes	No
0399	Schuler, Helena Elizabeth	Yes	No
0519	Schuler, Herbert John	Yes	No
0397	Schuler, John Athur	Yes	No
0518	Schuler, Margaret Cecilia	No	Yes
0419	Schulkes-Anderson, Danielle CAM	Yes	No
0370	Shanying, Wang	Yes	No
0367	Shanying, Wang	Yes	No
0385	Shears, Jonathan Woodward	Yes	No
0410	Shears, Margie	Yes	No
0029	Shinnie, Sarah	Yes	No
0222	Silvester, Carol	Yes	No
0873	Singh-Thandi, Makhan & Harpal	Yes	No
0233	Smith, Anthony James	Yes	No
0714	Smith, Jessica	No	Yes
0340	Sparks, Andrew Peter	Yes	No
0540	Spelchan, Christine Anne	Yes	No
0422	Stansfield, John & Sally	Yes	No
0407	Stevens, Catherine	Yes	No
0408	Stevens, Dominic	Yes	No
0095	Stewart, Beveley F	Yes	No
0377	Stovell, Diana Wendy	Yes	No
0378	Stovell, Richard	Yes	No
0404	Suherman, Hardi	Yes	No
0394	Summers, Karl	No	Yes
0762	Tabor, Mark	Yes	No
0379	Tait, Christine Brenda	Yes	No
0766	Takerei, Ngaire A	Yes	No
1061	Tarrant, Steve	No	Yes
0674	Taylor, Angela	Yes	No
0638	Taylor, Jeffery D	No	Yes
0673	Taylor, Joanne S	Yes	No
0675	Taylor, Malcolm J	Yes	No
0647	Tebbutt, Joy W	Yes	No
0646	Tebbutt, Kenneth	Yes	No
0909	Teng, Daniel	Yes	No
0746	Teng, Jinguo	Yes	No
0745	Teng, Lisa	Yes	No
0912	Teng, Xing guo	Yes	No
0859	Thomas, Bruce	No	Yes
1248	Thomas, David	No	Yes
0047	Tocher, Dawn	Yes	No
0895	Tonks, Brian	No	Yes
1030	Tonks, Charlotte F	Yes	No
0887	Tonks, Kevin	No	Yes
0892	Tonks, Paul	No	Yes
1031	Tonks, Richard W	Yes	No
0652	Townley, Maureen V	Yes	No
0466	Travers, Virginia	No	Yes
0389	Trevethick, Shani & Richard	No	Yes
1005	Vallings, Brendan K	No	No
0846	Vallings, Rosamund	No	Yes
0824	Van Doorn, Martin	No	Yes
0732	Van Maanen, Max	Yes	No
1101	Van Rhyn, Paula	Yes	No
0355	Walker, Andrea Joan	Yes	No
0356	Walker, Joan	Yes	No
1050	Wallace, Eon	Yes	No
0828	Wallwork, Denise & Pellett, Selwyn	Yes	No
0834	Wallwork, Eunice	Yes	No
0836	Wallwork, Jerry	Yes	No
0291	Walters, Clyde	Yes	No
0414	Watts, Campbell Fraser	Yes	No
0415	Watts, Margaret Rosemary	Yes	No
0416	Watts, Paul Campbell	Yes	No
0418	Watts, Timothy Steven	No	Yes
0102	Waugh, Mary	Yes	No
0666	Webby, Geraldine M	Yes	No
0923	Webster, Deborah A	No	Yes
0639	Wells, Geoffrey A	Yes	No
0093	Welsh, Candace	Yes	No
0069	Wesselink, Erica	Yes	No
0126	White, Christopher Ian Trevor	Yes	No
0811	White, David & Debra	Yes	No
0417	White, Owen & Carole	Yes	No
0528	Wilkins, Frank	Yes	No
0636	Williams, Julie	Yes	No
1003	Wiltshire, Kevin G	Yes	No
0535	Wood, Leonard	Yes	No
0073	Worth, Simon	Yes	No
0916	Wright, Anthony S	Yes	No
0521	Wyatt, Kym Maree	Yes	No
0369	Yan, Chen	Yes	No
0368	Yan, Chen	Yes	No
0911	Yeap, Rena	Yes	No
0747	Yeap, Rena	Yes	No
0120	Young, Catherine Jane	Yes	No
0371	Zhengyu, He	Yes	No

See more on...

Appendix 3

March 2008

Pūtaiao Facts and Science

He mahi ka taea e koe What you can do

Ā mātou mahi What government is doing

Te ao Māori The Māori world

Ngā Ture Acts and regulations

Pūtaiao Facts and Science

He mahi ka taea e koe What you can do

Ā mātou mahi What government is doing

Te ao Māori The Māori world

Ngā Ture Acts and regulations

Appendix 3

Type A Sample

See more on...

As New Zealand’s lead advisor on the environment and climate, we enable people and places to thrive, now and in the future

About this site

Contact us

Find us on

Pūtaiao Facts and Science

He mahi ka taea e koe What you can do

Ā mātou mahi What government is doing

Te ao Māori The Māori world

Ngā Ture Acts and regulations

Pūtaiao Facts and Science

He mahi ka taea e koe What you can do

Ā mātou mahi What government is doing

Te ao Māori The Māori world

Ngā Ture Acts and regulations

Appendix 3

Share

Share

Share

Type A Sample

See more on...