Documents re long term Earth temperatures

Details of the request

* Please provide any records (e.g. documents, emails, notes or minutes) mentioning scientists Ned Nikolov and/or Kari Zeller and/or Dr Roy Spencer as mentioned in the link below. For context - so that you can correctly identify the individuals - some links relevant to their work are mentioned in the links below. 1) 2017 Peer Reviewed and Published Paper Describing How Earth's Long Term Average Temperature can be estimated from NASA data on other planets without referencing the composition of Earth's atmosphere. That is, the finding is that CO2 does not have an impact on the long term average temperature of Earth. https://www.omicsonline.org/open-access/New-Insights-on-the-Physical-Nat... 2) Blog reply by Ned Nikolov in response to a critique by Dr Roy Spencer https://tallbloke.wordpress.com/2019/01/17/nikolov-zeller-reply-to-dr-ro...

* Please provide any records (including but not limited to internal/external: documents, emails, notes, minutes, text messages, or social media messages) mentioning scientists Dr Ronan Connolly and/or Michael Connolly and/or Christopher Monckton. For context - so that you can correctly identify the individuals - some links relevant to their work are mentioned in the links below. 1) This is the presentation of their findings that Earth's atmosphere is in thermo-dynamic equilibrium (directly opposite to a key IPCC assumption), and therefore CO2 cannot have any significant effect on the temperature of Earth's atmosphere. https://youtu.be/XfRBr7PEawY or https://t.co/FolJ8vWmGL?amp=1 2) This is the Connolly's blog site where they publish their results: https://globalwarmingsolved.com/ 3) This is where their empirical discovery is talked about by Christopher Monckton as a potential Nobel Prize winning paper (once published). https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1103&v=k6iOOuZCE_Y or https://t.co/gPBhw9GolD?amp=1

* Please provide any records (including but not limited to internal/external: documents, emails, notes, minutes, text messages, or social media messages) mentioning scientist Patrick Frank. For context - so that you can correctly identify the individual - some links relevant to his work are mentioned in the links below. 1) This is the peer reviewed paper (published on 6 September 2019) which finds that the statistical techniques used for forecasting global surface air temperature have not used an appropriate error propagation technique - and are therefore unreliable forecasts for the IPCC or governments to be using for policiy decisions. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feart.2019.00223/full or https://t.co/tdnQhjzDCS?amp=1 2) This is Patrick Frank's blog about his paper when it was published - which was rather scathing and impolite. https://wattsupwiththat.com/2019/09/07/propagation-of-error-and-the-reli... or https://t.co/VxX54HJh7f?amp=1

ministerials@mfe.govt.nz